- Details
- By Kaili Berg
Last week, the Yocha Dehe Wintun Nation publicly released its official comments on the Department of the Interior’s (DOI) Environmental Assessment (EA) of the proposed Scotts Valley Band of Pomo Indians casino project in Vallejo, CA.
The Yocha Dehe tribe, which has strong ancestral ties to the region, criticized the EA as an inadequate and deeply flawed document that fails to meet the basic requirements of federal environmental law, including the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA).
The Scotts Valley Band of Pomo Indians, who do not have ancestral ties to the Vallejo area, first proposed building the off-reservation casino with the backing of Las Vegas developers in 2016. The EA was published on July 8, 2024.
In its critique, the Yocha Dehe tribe described the EA as an “indecipherable mess” consisting of outdated information, incomplete data, and numerous inaccuracies. The tribe also highlighted that some of the site plans included in the EA were so poorly drafted that they depicted water flowing uphill.
According to a statement, the tribe’s primary concern revolves around the project’s potential to cause irreversible environmental damage and desecrate a Patwin cultural site.
The Yocha Dehe argues that the EA’s analysis was rushed and aimed at reaching a pre-determined outcome rather than conducting a genuine assessment of the environmental impacts.
The tribe’s comments assert that the EA grossly overlooked the project’s effects on endangered species, wetland habitats, and air quality. The analysis of traffic impacts was based on nearly two-decades-old data, leading to significant misrepresentations of the potential congestion and safety hazards.
The Yocha Dehe asserted that EA also failed to address critical issues related to grading, drainage, stormwater management, and wildfire risks and that the project’s engineering plans are “physically impossible.”
The tribe further stated that the EA excluded the voices of Patwin tribes and neglected to incorporate important Indigenous knowledge into its analysis.
The tribe also criticized the EA for omitting mention of the Solano Ranch project, a mixed-use development that is proposed for the same site, as well as a planned hotel and residential homes.
Yocha Dehe has joined a coalition of local tribes, municipal and county governments, and environmental groups in calling on the BIA to prepare a comprehensive Environmental Impact Statement.
Such an assessment, the tribe argues, would provide a more thorough and unbiased evaluation of the project’s potential impacts and consider less damaging alternatives.
Yocha Dehe’s comments come amid increasing opposition to the Scotts Valley casino project. Governor Gavin Newsom recently voiced his concerns, adding weight to the calls for a more rigorous environmental review.
Native New Online reached out out to the Scotts Valley Band of Pomo Indians for comment but did not hear back by press time/
More Stories Like This
Yurok Tribe Receives $18M for Restoration, Resumes Revegetation Work on Undammed Klamath RiverBiden-Harris Administration, NOAA Designate 3rd-largest National Marine Sanctuary
Tribal Delegation Pressure Congress to Pass Radiation Exposure Compensation Act
Sioux Chef Sean Sherman Named to The Independent’s Climate 100 List
Apache Stronghold Takes Oak Flat Fight to Supreme Court
Join our Founder’s Circle: a special group of supporters who are dedicated to ensuring that Native News Online can thrive and deliver impactful, independent journalism. To join the Founder's Circle, we ask that you make a monthly recurring contribution of $15 or more or a one-time donation of $175 or more.
